EG4 Community Forum

18Kpv does not top ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

18Kpv does not top balance or fully charge battery bank

8 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
188 Views
Posts: 102
Topic starter
(@jlankford)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 months ago

My 18Kpv does not top balance, nor even fully charge, my battery bank.

This is a whole house backup system consisting of one 18Kpv and six LL-S in an EG4 rack. No PV. System includes a Chargeverter permanently connected to the rack bus with a 120VAC generator input.

Battery bank and inverter system has been installed for about a month now. I have performed two backup discharge tests, pulling the SOC to 20% and then restoring grid power and letting the inverter fully charge the bank. So all batteries have been cycled to 20% and back to 100% at least twice. In addition to that, looking at the data history it appears the inverter periodically enters a charge cycle and brings the battery bank back to 100%.

Recently I installed the Chargeverter and performed a charging test. Battery bank at the start of the test was at 98% SOC (five batteries at 100% and one at 88%, which itself is an issue for another post). Chargeverter was configured for a modest 26 A of charging current, because my use case is to use a small 1600 watt 120VAC generator only as a last resort for a grid outage lasting more than two days. I ran the Chargeverter until the battery voltage finally ramped up to 56.0 VDC (the set charging voltage). All batteries were charging equally at about 4A each. It took a total of six hours of charging at a constant ~24 A, 4 A at each battery, before the current started to slowly drop and the voltage began to slowly rise. That’s a total of 144 Ah, including 24 Ah into each battery which started at 100 Ah, and 8,064 Wh of charging energy, or 24% of the total capacity of this battery bank. It took two more hours of charging during the ramp up period before all six batteries ceased charging and entered standby. I estimate another 15 to 20 Ah went into the bank during that final two hours for a total charge of 164 Ah or 9,184 Wh, which is 30% of the capacity of this battery bank that was showing 98% SOC at the start of the charging test.

So clearly the 18Kpv has not been bringing these batteries to a full charge and has thus never reset the BMS 100% reference point to something closer to full. It appears the 18Kpv stops charging immediately upon seeing a 100% SOC reported by the battery BMS and does not continue applying a charge voltage past that point, so there’s no opportunity for performing an equalization charge or to top-balance the battery bank. Looking at the data history for an inverter charging cycle, I never see the vBat data parameter go higher than 54.5 before the inverter has stopped charging.

The inverter is operating in closed loop, and the charging control is set for SOC rather than voltage, as recommended in the manual. AC Charging is enabled, Power Backup is enabled, and Stop Charging setting is 100% SOC.

@jared

Questions

  1. What charging voltage is the 18Kpv using? There is no adjustable setting for this value and I can’t locate an absolute value anywhere in the manual or inverter specifications.
  2. What settings should be changed to cause the inverter to fully charge the battery bank? Should the charge control setting be changed from SOC to Voltage, despite the manual’s recommendation for closed loop operation to use SOC?
  3. If setting inverter to Volt charge control, are the control setting values for Start & Stop referenced to the vBat or the Vbat_Inv data parameter? For Start operation this isn’t a critical question since the two data values track close to each other during standby and discharge, but for Stop this is an important question. Note that vBat never reaches the charging voltage at the end of the charge cycle, while Vbat_Inv does. The difference is more than 0.5 volt.
  4. For the LL-S battery, how long should a top-balance charge voltage be applied when manually charging the battery? In other words, during charging, once the battery has stopped accepting charge current and has entered Standby, and the battery voltage has reached the charging voltage, how much longer should the charging voltage be applied if doing this manually using the Chargeverter in open loop? One hour? Stop charging immediately? Looking for a best-practice number here for battery health and longevity. Note that once the battery first enters Standby at the end of the charging cycle, it will then randomly alternate between Standby / Charging for another hour and continue accepting a significant amount of additional charging current. My question above is for after this period, when the battery enters and remains in Standby.
  5. What value should be used for the inverter Lithium Brand setting for the LL-S battery? The out of box value was 2, Signature Solar advised to set this to 1, and the 18Kpv manual states to use 0. It is currently set to 1.
  6. What value should be used for the System Charge SOC Limit setting? The out of box value was 101%, which I changed to 100% to match the Stop AC Charge SOC setting.
  7. What is the difference between the Power Backup setting (under the Application section) and the Battery Backup Mode setting under the Charge section? How are these two settings related to the “Start Battery Backup” function button on the monitor page?
  8. Does the LL-S BMS adjust and reset it's calculated SOC value over time? Does it move its 100% reference point upward whenever it measures additional charging current flowing into a battery that was already at 100%?

 

7 Replies
5 Replies
Jared
Admin
(@jared)
Joined: 3 months ago

Online Support
Posts: 247

Posted by: @jlankford

What charging voltage is the 18Kpv using? There is no adjustable setting for this value and I can’t locate an absolute value anywhere in the manual or inverter specifications. 

This depends on if BMS communication is being used or if the inverter is set to lead-acid battery type. With BMS communication, the charging voltage is set by the BMS, which is typically around 56.8v. When in lead-acid, this is configurable.

Posted by: @jlankford

What settings should be changed to cause the inverter to fully charge the battery bank? Should the charge control setting

System Charge SOC limit and Volt limit. I would recommend having the System Charge SOC Limit set to 101% to allow top balancing with EG4 batteries.

Posted by: @jlankford

If setting inverter to Volt charge control, are the control setting values for Start & Stop referenced to the vBat or the Vbat_Inv data parameter? For Start operation this isn’t a critical question since the two data values track close to each other during standby and discharge, but for Stop this is an important question. Note that vBat never reaches the charging voltage at the end of the charge cycle, while Vbat_Inv does. The difference is more than 0.5 volt.

With BMS communication, the voltage reading would be from VBat_INV. While open loop with lead-acid, this would be read from VBat.

Posted by: @jlankford

For the LL-S battery, how long should a top-balance charge voltage be applied when manually charging the battery? In other words, during charging, once the battery has stopped accepting charge current and has entered Standby, and the battery voltage has reached the charging voltage, how much longer should the charging voltage be applied if doing this manually using the Chargeverter in open loop? One hour? Stop charging immediately? Looking for a best-practice number here for battery health and longevity. Note that once the battery first enters Standby at the end of the charging cycle, it will then randomly alternate between Standby / Charging for another hour and continue accepting a significant amount of additional charging current. My question above is for after this period, when the battery enters and remains in Standby.

I will need to reach out to our battery team for an answer to this.

Posted by: @jlankford

What value should be used for the inverter Lithium Brand setting for the LL-S battery? The out of box value was 2, Signature Solar advised to set this to 1, and the 18Kpv manual states to use 0. It is currently set to 1.

Depending on the firmware and protocol available, it would either be 1 or 0. If the EG4/LUX protocol is available, I would recommend this be set to 1. However, if this is not, I would recommend having the battery protocol set to CAN EG4 with lithium brand 0.

Posted by: @jlankford

What value should be used for the System Charge SOC Limit setting? The out of box value was 101%, which I changed to 100% to match the Stop AC Charge SOC setting.

101% would be recommended to allow for top balancing.

Posted by: @jlankford

What is the difference between the Power Backup setting (under the Application section) and the Battery Backup Mode setting under the Charge section? How are these two settings related to the “Start Battery Backup” function button on the monitor page?

Power Backup allows for loads to be powered when grid is not present while battery backup will prioritize not using battery power until it is the last source of available power.

Posted by: @jlankford

Does the LL-S BMS adjust and reset it's calculated SOC value over time? Does it move its 100% reference point upward whenever it measures additional charging current flowing into a battery that was already at 100%?

The 100% reference will be recalibrated over time based on various factors, including the SOH and the available aH capacity.

Here are battery performance curves for the LL-S battery:

image

 

Reply
Joel Brodeur
(@joel-brodeur)
Joined: 3 months ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 204

@jared

Posted by: @jlankford

Posted by: @jlankford

What settings should be changed to cause the inverter to fully charge the battery bank? Should the charge control setting

 

System Charge SOC limit and Volt limit. I would recommend having the System Charge SOC Limit set to 101% to allow top balancing with EG4 batteries.

Not to highjack this thread but I think this would be considered related.  Does the same apply to the 6000xp with wall mount batteries?

I have a single 6000xp with 2 wall mount indoor batteries.  Compared to others my SOC discrepancy is very mild 1 to 3 percent.

I am completely Off-Grid so no utility power at all.  We are in winter and get very little solar.  I charge every few days from a gen.

When the inverter shuts down the gen my batteries seem to do a little dance as far as balancing almost like they are send a little current back and forth to match up.

So, the questions are:

1- For gen charging based on SOC on closed loop, should the charge to be set to 101%?

2 - If so, should this be done at all times or just occasionally to "top balance"?

3 - Will the batteries report 101% so that the gen shutdown on it's own?

Thanks,

JB

 

Reply
(@jlankford)
Joined: 2 months ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 102

@jared 

Thank you for your responses.

Is there a way to see what charging voltage the BMS is calling for? The monitor displays the BMS charge current limit, which I notice changes with DOD. But I can't find a "BMS voltage" data value anywhere.

The LL-S has the CAN:EG4/LUX protocol available and that’s what I have the master battery set to. So I’ll leave the inverter set to ‘1’.

Regarding the 101% value of the System Charge SOC Limit setting, I have the same question as Joel. Is this a practice that should be done continuously, or perhaps something that should be performed once a month (or less) for good battery health and longevity?

The same question applies if I decide to manually charge using the Chargeverter occasionally to maintain battery health… how often should I apply a top balance charge with the Chargeverter using the time duration you’re getting from the battery team?

Reply
(@jlankford)
Joined: 2 months ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 102

@jared 

Also, you didn’t answer the question about whether I should change charging control from “SOC” to “volt”. I’m inclined to change it to “volt” based on the behavior, if I can figure out what values to use for Start and Stop. Please note my latest comment on my other thread under battery support. My bank is now down to about 65%, but the reported SOC is still at 98%. It appears the BMS is never going to kick off a new charge cycle. Also I just noticed the BMS Limit Charge value is still at a low value of 75A. With the battery voltages at the 65% level that charge limit should be much higher – this seems to be another clue that the BMS really thinks it’s at nearly full charge and isn’t going to call for a charge cycle any time soon (if that’s how closed loop works).

Reply
(@jlankford)
Joined: 2 months ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 102

@jared 

I think I found the BMS charging voltage value in the data history. I see a value named "ChargeVoltRef(V)", which is presently at 56.0V. Is this it?

Reply
Posts: 102
Topic starter
(@jlankford)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 months ago

Question #9

What is the discharge current measurement threshold for the LL-S BMS? I have encountered other LiFePO4 battery brands that have a relatively high threshold for the discharge current used to calculate SOC. There is one brand that does not include any discharge current below 1.0A in its SOC calculations, according to their engineering department, and so that battery can slowly discharge but will continue to report 100% SOC. Is it possible that my LL-S batteries are each slowly discharging at something less than 0.5A due to the inverter’s continuous EPS standby current load, and the batteries (all but one) are not changing the SOC value from 100% because the current is below some threshold?

Reply
Posts: 102
Topic starter
(@jlankford)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 months ago

Question #9 has been moved to another thread under battery support.

Reply
Share: