I was on a support call with Signaturesolar.com a talking through peak shaving, and at some point was told discharge below 20% SOC would damage the battery. Is this true? I'd like to be able to get more than 80% from my battery.
I was on a support call with Signaturesolar.com a talking through peak shaving, and at some point was told discharge below 20% SOC would damage the battery. Is this true? I'd like to be able to get more than 80% from my battery.
The documentation indicates a setting no lower than 20% SOC is recommended.
EG4®-Indoor-280Ah-Battery-Specifications-Sheet.pdf
My rudimentary opinion is as follows:
1 - a manufacturer recommendation usually means that it would/could void warranty. I do not know EG4's stance on this.
2 - if you look at the discharge curve ( https://forum.eg4electronics.com/community/postid/816/) you will see that the last 20% drops fairly quickly, you won't be getting too much out of it.
3 - Remember that the BMS is going to shut down when cell voltage reaches 2.3 volts, so depending on how low you take it, you might trigger a BMS to go into low voltage shutdown.
Just my opinion. I am paranoid about warranties and am always hesitant to go outside recommended operating parameters unless I have written recommendations from the manufacturer.
As far as damage? I am not sure about that. Will Prowse has done some videos regarding DOD and battery life cycles. You might check out his YouTube channel (DIY Solar Power with Will Prowse - YouTube) and see if you agree or disagree.
Best of luck and please keep us posted as to what you discover.
JB
Sometimes the easiest solution is the best solution.
Sometimes not.
@joel-brodeur That all makes good sense. I have watched that Will Prowse youtube which made me wonder.
cc @jared Maybe the EG4 team can provide a whitepaper on this topic? Dispell some of the myths and offer clarity.
I believe this whitepaper on maximizing battery lifespan primarily covers this topic:
That said, no damage will occur if the depth of discharge falls below 20%. However, consistently discharging below 20% may reduce the expected cycle life, which is rated for 7,000 cycles at 80% DoD.
Thank you for sharing that information. Seems to confirm storing SOC , but no issue discharging below 20% as long as it is recharged back. No warranty issue mentioned.
And, for reference, here's that video by Wipp Prowse
@bobandroslyn Good information. 🙂
Sometimes the easiest solution is the best solution.
Sometimes not.